Pine Island FL Vacations: A Laid-Back Gulf Coast Escape
If you’re dreaming of a Florida getaway without the crowds, neon lights, or high-rises, Pine Island may be the place you’ve been searching for. Tucked between Sanibel, Captiva, and Cape Coral, this unspoiled island feels more like old Florida than a modern resort town. Pine Island vacations are about slowing down, watching the tides roll in, and savoring the simple pleasures of Gulf Coast living.
Mangrove-lined shores, quiet fishing villages, and a colorful artists’ enclave at Matlacha make Pine Island unlike anywhere else on Florida’s southwest coast. Here, fresh-caught seafood shows up on your plate within hours of leaving the boat, and cozy motels perch right over the water where dolphins sometimes pass by. Whether you’re here to cast a line, explore ancient Calusa shell mounds, kayak peaceful estuaries, or just sip a cold drink at a dockside café, Pine Island invites you to step into its easy rhythm and stay awhile.
MAP OF PINE ISLAND FLORIDA
History of Pine Island
Long before fishermen and artists found their way to Pine Island, the Calusa people thrived here for more than a thousand years. They left behind massive shell mounds, canals, and artifacts that still mark the landscape, particularly around Pineland. Spanish explorers arrived in the 1500s and wrote of encounters with the Calusa, a people who dominated the waters of southwest Florida.
By the 19th century, settlers established small farms, groves, and fishing operations. Pine Island grew slowly, shaped by hurricanes, tides, and its isolation from the mainland. Fishing, boat building, and agriculture became the backbone of the island’s economy—traditions that still linger in today’s communities of Bokeelia, Pineland, Matlacha, St. James City, and Pine Island Center.
Pine Island Demographics
Pine Island is not a bustling metropolis—it’s a collection of small, close-knit communities with a population numbering in the low thousands. Many residents are retirees drawn by the tranquil pace, while others are long-time families connected to commercial fishing and maritime trades. The median age is higher than the Florida average, giving the island a laid-back, mature vibe. You’ll also find seasonal snowbirds who migrate south for the winter months, as well as artists, boat captains, and nature lovers who value Pine Island’s slower rhythm.
Life on Pine Island
Life here is guided by tides and sunsets rather than traffic lights and deadlines. The island has no beaches like nearby Sanibel, but that’s part of its charm—mangroves and estuaries define its shores, creating habitats for birds, fish, and marine life. Days are filled with fishing trips, art walks in Matlacha, bike rides under palm trees, and simple moments like sharing stories at a dockside café.
Neighbors know one another, and local traditions are strong. Fishing tournaments, art festivals, and small markets bring the community together, while the island’s preserved lands and waters remind everyone of the balance between people and nature.
Pine Island Today
Despite its proximity to Cape Coral and Fort Myers, Pine Island feels worlds apart. Development has been carefully managed to maintain its rural, maritime character. Local plans emphasize preserving wetlands, archaeological sites, and the commercial fishing heritage that still sustains many families. While real estate interest has grown, restrictions and the island’s limited infrastructure have kept Pine Island from overdevelopment. The result is an island that remains unhurried, authentic, and deeply tied to the water.
Pine Island Historic Sites
- Pineland Archaeological Site: One of the most important Calusa heritage sites in Florida, with shell mounds and remnants of canals offering a glimpse into pre-Columbian life.
-
Historic Surveys: Pine Island’s older homes and fishing cottages in St. James City, Pineland, and Bokeelia reflect its early 20th-century working waterfront roots.
- Matlacha’s Main Street: Not officially historic, but filled with brightly painted shops and galleries that celebrate the island’s creative spirit and fishing past.
Things to Do on Pine Island SW Florida
Get on the Water
Fishing charters, kayak rentals, and paddleboard trips are the heartbeat of Pine Island vacations. Anglers head out for snook, redfish, and tarpon, while paddlers glide through quiet mangrove tunnels alive with herons, egrets, and the occasional dolphin.
Explore Preserves
Nature lovers can wander trails at Galt Preserve or the Calusa Island Preserve, both offering birdwatching and a sense of Florida’s coastal wilderness.
Discover Local Art
Matlacha is the island’s creative hub, with galleries, murals, and shops bursting with color. It’s an ideal place to browse local artwork and enjoy a laid-back stroll.
Sample Fresh Seafood
Stone crab, shrimp, and grouper are mainstays on Pine Island menus. Stop by a dockside market or waterfront restaurant to taste the day’s catch.
The Towns and Villages of Pine Island
- Matlacha: A quirky, colorful artists’ enclave with galleries, seafood restaurants, and a fun, bohemian energy.
- Bokeelia: At the island’s northern tip, Bokeelia is a working harbor town known for fishing, boating, and stunning water views.
- Pineland: A quieter community steeped in Calusa history and home to archaeological sites.
-
St. James City: The southern end of Pine Island, filled with marinas, waterfront homes, and casual dockside restaurants.
-
Pine Island Center: The island’s service hub with shops, groceries, and community facilities.
Pine Island Real Estate
Real estate here is as varied as the island itself. Waterfront homes with docks and deepwater access command the highest prices, while older fishing cottages and inland properties remain more affordable. Buyers are often retirees, boaters, or those seeking vacation rentals. Flood insurance, hurricane preparedness, and zoning rules are important factors when purchasing property. What Pine Island offers that many other Florida destinations don’t is authenticity—a chance to live in a community still tied to fishing, art, and nature rather than tourism alone.
Where to Eat & Stay
When planning Pine Island vacations, expect laid-back seafood shacks, colorful waterfront cafés, and cozy lodging that feels more like a friend’s beach cottage than a resort.
Blue Dog Bar & Grill
4597 Pine Island Road, Matlacha, FL 33993 | (239) 558-4970
Local seafood with creative flair in a lively, art-filled setting. Famous for crab cakes and fish tacos.
Miceli’s Restaurant
3930 Pine Island Road, Matlacha, FL 33993 | (239) 282-8233
Pizza, pasta, live music, and dockside dining make this Matlacha favorite a must.
Island Pho & Grill
1041 NW Pine Island Road Unit 14, Cape Coral, FL 33993 | (239) 257-2803
A refreshing change from seafood, this nearby spot offers Vietnamese pho and grilled dishes.
Waterfront Restaurant & Marina
3422 Stringfellow Road, St. James City, FL 33956 | (239) 283-0592
A casual, dockside hangout known for sunsets, cold drinks, and easygoing seafood meals.
Lazy Flamingo 3
16501 Stringfellow Road, Bokeelia, FL 33922 | (239) 283-5959
Known for “you hook it, we cook it” dining, with fresh fish, shrimp, and wings in a laid-back setting.
Knoll’s Court Motel
4601 Pine Island Road, Matlacha, FL 33993 | (239) 283-0616
Retro cottages right on the water, filled with old-Florida charm.
Bridgewater Inn
4331 Pine Island Road, Matlacha, FL 33993 | (239) 283-2423
Perched over the water, this inn lets guests fish from their balcony or watch dolphins pass by.
Angler’s Inn
15161 Stringfellow Road, Bokeelia, FL 33922 | (239) 283-2929
A fisherman’s base with comfortable rooms and close access to marinas and charters.
Vacation Rentals
Scattered across Matlacha, Bokeelia, Pineland, and St. James City
Private cottages and waterfront homes are ideal for longer stays, offering dock access, full kitchens, and a true island-living feel.
Closing Thoughts: A Pine Island Vacation
Pine Island isn’t a place you “do”—it’s a place you feel. It’s early mornings on the dock with a fishing rod, afternoons wandering Matlacha’s galleries, and evenings watching the sun slip below the mangroves with a plate of fresh seafood in front of you. For travelers searching for authentic Florida, Pine Island vacations deliver a slower, richer experience—one where history, culture, and nature blend seamlessly.
Come for the fishing, the food, the art, or simply the peace and quiet. Connect with Florida’s past. Stay because Pine Island has a way of getting into your heart and reminding you that the best vacations are the ones that make you feel at home.
Hotels and Vacation Rentals Near Matlacha, Florida, USA
SWFL REALTORS & REAL ESTATE AGENTS
Becky Irwin Realtor® | 954-249-0374
Becky Irwin has been Florida resident for more than 30 years. Her family moved full time to Marco Island in 1980 and then to Fort Lauderdale in 1983. Becky is intimately familiar with both the east-coast (Broward) and west-coast (Collier) communities of Florida. A graduate of both St. Thomas Aquinas High School and Florida State University, she has deep roots and connections across South Florida. Becky is a licensed Florida Broker Associate, a member of the Marco Island Area Association of Realtors, Naples Area Board of Realtors and the Realtor Association of Greater Fort Lauderdale.
Visit Becky Irwin Realtor Listings
Marco Expert - Patrick J. Wilkins Realtor® | 239-260-3550
Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist. When you are ready to buy or sell on Marco Island contact the Wilkins Team. Personally sold Over $950 Million. Member RE/MAX Affinity Plus. #1 RE/MAX Agent Worldwide 2004. Browse our website for Marco Island real estate market research, covering all the surrounding areas as well.
Visit Marco Expert - Marco Island, FL
Matt Brown, William Raveis Real Estate, 720 Fifth Avenue South, Naples, FL 34102 | 239-580-8864
Specializing in luxury homes and condominiums, Matt Brown has 18+ years of experience marketing and selling exceptional properties. He has closed over $500 million and skillfully negotiated over 100 highest and best multiple-bid sales. Unparalleled focus on every detail, his reputation continues to set the bar high in the industry.
Matt Brown, Bonita Springs, Estero, Naples, FL Real Estate Agent
PINE ISLAND FLORIDA GIFTS
SWFL PARADISE COAST ATTRACTIONS
Avi's Water Sports Jet Ski Adventure Tours, Caxambas Park, 909 Collier Ct., Marco Island, FL 34145 | 239-777-9873
Avi's is a family-owned business that offers some of the most exciting dolphin jet ski tours and jet ski rental adventures on Marco Island. You are invited to take an exciting journey with Avi "The Dolphin Whisperer" and take home a complimentary flash drive of photos from your adventure. Bring the family and make lasting memories. Contact us to book your dolphin Jet Ski tour.
Avi's Water Sports & Jet Ski Adventure Tours - Marco Island, FL
Sunshine Tours and Fishing Charters, Rose Marina, 951 Bald Eagle Dr., Marco Island, FL | 239-642-5415
Sunshine Tours. Fish the 10,000 islands, the best in Off Shore, Back Water, and Near Coastal Fishing Charters. We know where the fish are. Also offering Marco Island Shelling Trips, and Sightseeing aboard one of our four fishing boats. Since 1984, Sunshine Tours has provided unsurpassed fishing charters, and on-the-water experiences for locals and visitors alike. Shared and private charters available. Contact us to book your Marco Island fishing charter.
Sunshine Tours & Charters - Marco Island, FL
Skinny Dipn Charters - Fishing & Eco Tours, Marco Island, FL 34145 | 239-207-1945
Marco Island Fishing and Sightseeing Tour from an experienced Captain and Guide. Growing up on the local waters of Marco Island, Captain Brandon's excitement for fishing began at a very young age. He is highly knowledgeable of all the different fish species and waterways. Brandon is a very outgoing, personable, skilled, and patient. He takes pride in sharing his passion for fishing and helping his clients catch their dream fish!
Skinny Dipn Charters & Eco Tours - Marco Island
Marco Island Princess / Sunshine Tours, Rose Marina, 951 Bald Eagle Dr., Marco Island FL 34145 | 239-642-5415
The Marco Island Princess is a 90' luxury yacht offering daily Sightseeing, Lunch and Sunset Dinner Cruises. All of our delicious meals are prepared fresh on board for your enjoyment. Our professional and friendly crew will attend to your every need. Two full service cash bars serving up all of your favorite drinks! Also available for Weddings and Private Charters. Marco Island's most unique dining experience!
Visit The Marco Island Princess - Marco Island, FL
Island Bike Shops (2 Locations) 1095 Bald Eagle Dr., Marco Island, FL 34145 | 239-394-8400 & 4342 Thomasson Dr., Naples, FL 34112 | 239-732-8400
At Island Bike Shops we make your visit fun. Reserve your rental online. Check our selection of bicycle rentals, electric bikes, motor scooters, trailers, and more. Naples Bicycle Tours provides a unique opportunity for residents and visitors to experience the diversity of Southwest Florida. Our large or small group bicycle tours can accommodate all cycling levels as we personally escort you through Naples, Historic Old Naples, Marco Island, or the Natural Everglades.
Visit Island Bike Shops - Marco Island & Naples
Naples Bicycle Tours, Naples, FL 34113 | 239-580-7960
Naples Bicycle Tours provides a unique opportunity for visitors and residents to experience the natural Florida Everglades, up close and personal. Connect with nature on this 3-hour historic & ecotour in the heart of the Glades. All tours include everything needed for the adventure: custom-fit cycle, helmet, drinks, snacks, and a certified FL naturalist guide.
Naples Bicycle Tours - Naples, FL
Go Cats On The Water 2200 Tamiami Trail E, Collier Seminole State Park, Naples, FL | 239-748-4099
Marco and Naples Most Exciting Boat Tour. Explore the backwater and mangroves for an unforgettable adventure in Southwest Florida. Everglades Backwater Sightseeing Eco-Tours in our safe, and easy to drive boats. Choose a 75 minute or a 2.5 hour tour. Our custom Go-Cat boats are fun for all ages and can easily be operated by both younger adults and seniors. Kayak, and Canoe rentals now available.
GoCatsOnTheWater.com - Naples, FL
Tropical Tiki Tours, 220 Goodland Dr., Goodland, FL | 941-208-1200
Discover your private paradise on our new 26' "tiki-style" catamaran for a fun and relaxing cruise around Marco Island. Tropical Tiki Tours is offering daily eco-tours, sunset cruises, and private trips from 2-6 hours. Our USCG-inspected vessel is certified for up to 18 passengers so there is always room for all your family and friends for, Private Trips, Eco Tours, Corporate Events, Birthdays, Bachelorettes, Weddings, and Sunset Cruises.
Tropical Tiki Tours - Goodland, FL
Contact Us
Explore
the Best of
SW FLORIDA
Shop Free World Mall
Amazon Big Deals
Amazon Big Deals